News Summary
Memphis faces a contentious debate over PILOT tax breaks, with supporters claiming they stimulate growth and critics arguing they harm public services. Recent approvals raised questions about their necessity, as data shows many businesses could thrive without them. The financial toll of these incentives on local education is significant, leading to immediate calls for increased oversight and evaluation. As discussions continue, the future of PILOT programs remains uncertain, balancing business interests against community needs.
Memphis is currently facing a heated debate surrounding the use of tax breaks for businesses, particularly through PILOTs (Payments in lieu of taxes). Supporters claim that these incentives are crucial for stimulating economic growth in the region, while critics argue that they disproportionately divert vital revenue from public services, such as local schools and essential community programs.
Estimates indicate that PILOTs in Memphis could waive approximately $700 million in taxes over a ten-year period. In 2024 alone, the Memphis Economic Development Growth Engine (EDGE) approved 266 PILOT agreements, resulting in waivers of about $19.4 million in county taxes and an estimated $14 million in city taxes. Additional waivers amounting to $17 million in county taxes were also approved by the Downtown Memphis Commission and the Memphis Health, Educational, and Housing Facility Board.
Despite the financial incentives offered by PILOTs, research suggests that approximately 75% of businesses receiving these tax breaks would likely have established operations in Memphis without the financial incentives. This raises questions about the necessity and effectiveness of such programs in truly enhancing the local economy.
Across the United States, nearly 95% of cities offer some form of tax incentives. Notably, cities like Pittsburgh and Indianapolis have begun refining their tax incentive criteria. In Indianapolis, companies must pay a minimum wage of $18/hour to qualify for incentives and are required to invest a portion of their tax savingsโ5%โinto local services, such as public transit and childcare. In Philadelphia, there is a cap on tax breaks, which are limited to 10 years and decrease in value by 10% each subsequent year.
The approval process for PILOTs in Memphis involves oversight from multiple public boards. However, accountability and review processes are infrequent, contributing to a lack of transparency regarding the effectiveness of these tax waivers. Since 2014, Shelby County alone has forfeited nearly $41 million annually in tax revenue due to PILOT agreements, significantly impacting essential services such as education.
Critics argue that the financial losses incurred from PILOTs, which create a situation where taxes benefiting local schools are waived, have resulted in an estimated $175 million loss for education over a decade’s time. Reports indicate that Memphis-Shelby County Schools are currently confronted with nearly $1 billion in delayed maintenance, a situation that many believe could be alleviated with the revenue lost from tax breaks.
The plight of low-income housing has also come under scrutiny, particularly with tax incentives overseen by the Health, Educational and Housing Facility Board. Concerns about transparency and management practices have surfaced, with complaints regarding hazardous living conditions in properties that benefit from PILOTs, such as Grahamwood Place. Residents have reported serious maintenance issues that remain unresolved, despite the financial incentives awarded to developers for affordable housing initiatives.
Supporters of PILOTs argue that these tax breaks drive new investments and foster commercial activity, essential components for a healthy local economy. However, many critics contend that the incentives primarily serve to enrich large corporations rather than benefitting the community as a whole.
As the debate continues, a Shelby County Board ad-hoc committee is currently reviewing PILOT programs with the aim of enhancing evaluations, improving oversight, and holding companies more accountable. The need for efficient public service funding in Memphis remains a pressing concern that may hinge upon the outcomes of this ongoing reassessment of tax breaks for businesses.
Deeper Dive: News & Info About This Topic
HERE Resources
Increased Booking Times Raise Concerns at Shelby County Jail
Javier Bailey Announces Candidacy for Shelby County Assessor
New Tax Deductions for Seniors Announced
Republicans Unveil Controversial New Tax Bill
Memphis Launches ‘Entrepreneurship City’ Program for Local Businesses
LifeScience Logistics Expands to Memphis with $23.2 Million Investment
Shelby County Commission to Discuss Budget Amendments
Downtown Memphis Development Gains Momentum with New Projects
Memphis-Shelby County Schools Approve $1.9 Billion Budget
Memphis-Shelby County Schools Board Approves $1.95 Billion Budget
Additional Resources
- MLK50: Tax Breaks Propped Up a Troubled Memphis Apartment Complex
- Wikipedia: Tax Incentives
- Fox13 Memphis: Which Companies Received $1.5 Billion in Tax Breaks
- Google Search: Memphis tax breaks
- Tennessee Lookout: World’s Top Businesses Receive Biggest Tennessee Tax Rebates
- Encyclopedia Britannica: Tax Break
- MLK50: Tax Breaks Drain Millions from Shelby County Coffers
- Google News: PILOT Programs in Memphis
Author: STAFF HERE MEMPHIS WRITER
The MEMPHIS STAFF WRITER represents the experienced team at HEREMemphis.com, your go-to source for actionable local news and information in Memphis, Shelby County, and beyond. Specializing in "news you can use," we cover essential topics like product reviews for personal and business needs, local business directories, politics, real estate trends, neighborhood insights, and state news affecting the areaโwith deep expertise drawn from years of dedicated reporting and strong community input, including local press releases and business updates. We deliver top reporting on high-value events such as Beale Street Music Festival, Elvis Week, and Memphis in May International Festival. Our coverage extends to key organizations like the Greater Memphis Chamber and the Memphis Convention & Visitors Bureau, plus leading businesses in logistics, healthcare, and music that power the local economy such as FedEx, St. Jude Children's Research Hospital, and AutoZone. As part of the broader HERE network, including HEREBristol.com, HEREChattanooga.com, HEREKnoxville.com, and HERENashville.com, we provide comprehensive, credible insights into Tennessee's dynamic landscape.
