MONTGOMERY, Ala. — Jeremy Pruitt’s $100 million legal fight with the NCAA is over, at least in Alabama. The Alabama Supreme Court on Friday ordered a DeKalb County judge to throw out the former Tennessee Vols football coach’s lawsuit, ruling that the county court never had jurisdiction over the association.
Justices split 6-3 in a 93-page opinion granting the NCAA’s request for a writ of mandamus.
The majority said the case was rooted elsewhere. The investigation, interviews and disciplinary hearings behind Pruitt’s claims played out in Tennessee, Indiana and Ohio, not Alabama, and the court observed that Pruitt only relocated to DeKalb County after the NCAA inquiry had begun. Justice Will Sellers, concurring in the result, wrote that the law demands a meaningful link between what a defendant did in the state and the dispute at hand.
Three justices disagreed. In dissent, Justice Tom Bryan noted that 18 NCAA member schools in Alabama received the show-cause order, which he said tied the hiring limits directly to Pruitt’s complaint that his job prospects were damaged. Justice Jean Brown Wise signed on with Bryan, while Justice Jay Mitchell Parker filed a dissent of his own.
The decision addresses only where the case could be heard. It does not resolve whether Pruitt’s allegations are true.
Pruitt sued in March 2025. Tennessee had fired him more than four years before that, amid a recruiting investigation. He accused the NCAA of working with the university to pin violations on him that he said came before his tenure, and argued the penalty cost him a shot at another college job. His suit also contended the NCAA punished him under rules undercut by the 2021 U.S. Supreme Court decision that cleared the way for NIL.
A DeKalb County judge granted him a preliminary injunction against the show-cause order in December 2025, but Pruitt later asked the court to lift it, saying schools still hesitated to hire a coach who might be forced out if he lost. The court dissolved it in April. The NCAA had already let Jacksonville State bring him on as an off-field analyst in October 2025 under a monitoring plan, and he resigned there March 31, 2026.
Pruitt now coaches defense at Plainview. His six-year show-cause penalty, handed down in July 2023, runs through July 13, 2029, so any NCAA school that wants to hire him for an athletics job must explain why the restrictions should not apply.
Section: More Memphis TN sports news
Memphis sports business profiles
Filed under: Memphis TN Sports News